I enjoyed my first Tessa Dare novel, A Week to be Wicked, so I figured I’d give Dare’s next novel in the series a try: A Lady by Midnight (2012). I’d already been introduced to the main characters in the previous novel. Kate Taylor is an orphan of unknown origins, raised in a strict school for ladies. Having been educated in the art of music at school, Kate earns a respectable living teaching music to students at Spindle Cove. Corporal Thorne has had more than a tough childhood himself as well as some time spent in jail, but he’s turned himself into a respectable and courageous military officer stationed at Spindle Cove.
Kate is very alone in the world with little prospects for marriage. Although she lives a comfortable life and likes teaching music, she yearns for a family. She’s noticed Corporal Thorne since he moved to Spindle Cove the year before, but he is always standoffish and rude to her. However, when she is stranded in town and Corporal Thorne comes to her aid–with a puppy!–things heat up.
At the same time, the Grammercy’s, an eccentric, but very rich family come to town and claim that Kate is her family. Kate is excited but Corporal Thorne is suspicious and they enter into an engagement in order for him to be in a better position to protect her.(?) I guess there is a little mystery surrounding Kate’s past, but it is not a large part of the story. What follows primarily is a push and pull between Kate and Corporal Thorne. She likes him. Yet even though he makes out with her every chance he gets, he’s decided that he’s incapable of love and unworthy of loving Kate.
Unfortunately, this is not one of my favorites. I much preferred A Week to be Wicked, which also had a ludicrous plot but was more fun to read. I liked Kate and thought she was a fun heroine, and I was a great fan of the puppy. However, Corporal Thorne is not my go-to hero. He’s so dark and brooding and he never acts like he actually likes Kate–except maybe for giving her the puppy, but that felt more like passive aggressive acquiescence than a well-meaning gift. I think I’ve figured out with this book that reluctant heroes are not my thing. It is just not sexy or romantic to be rebuffed and denied. Kate put her heart out there time and again and got nothing in return. When he finally gives in, I couldn’t understand what was different.
Usually I start reading a romance novel and I don’t put it down, but this one held very little urgency for me. It took me forever to read the last fifty pages. And instead of finding Thorne’s ***spoiler, not really*** “lock me up in jail” idea romantic, I was just irritated. Once again, Thorne runs away, blatantly ignoring Kate’s feelings, arrogantly ordering her to marry a man she doesn’t love, and making her do all the work to get them together! I’m not giving up on Dare, but I may pick more carefully in the future.
Find all of my reviews on my blog.
A Lady by Midnight is one of Dare’s weakest novels that I’ve read. Kate and Thorne’s story didn’t interest me all that much, and there were too many supporting characters distracting from the main story. The next one in the series, Any Duchess Will Do is one of my favourites, though, so you shouldn’t let one less than great book stop you from reading more of her books.
Thanks! I’ll make sure to check out Any Duchess Will do
I found the plotting heavy going and busy in this one. It seemed Dare was setting up her next series with Kate’s family and then decided to go in another direction when she actually got around to writing. There was just too much going on. I liked Thorne, but then I enjoy a big lug, and Dare writes exceptional smolder.
Yeah, the read A Week to be Wicked and quite liked it and everything since then has been a disappointment. I’m reading A Lady by Midnight right now and it’s just so blah. Plus, I’m pretty sure I’ve guessed most of the twists already.
I’ll definitely second Malin, and say you should read Any Duchess Will Do. It’s definitely one of Dare’s better ones!
Oh yes! And The Scandalous, Dissolute, No-Good Mr. Wright. It’s a gem.