To say I was hesitant about reading Jane Steele is a bit of an understatement. Yes, we had a few glowing, wonderful reviews from ElCicco and yesknopemaybe, and that should have been enough to convince me. But last year I read Jane, a modern retelling of Jane Eyre, and I hated it. HATED IT. I was wary about getting myself into another Jane Eyre story. But this isn’t a retelling of the classic, its more of an homage. And it kicks ass.
I’m going to go out on a limb and predict that this is going to be one of the Cannonball books of the year. There’s just too much to love for it not to become a favorite.
Jane Steele is a young woman in Victorian (I guess? The time is quite vague) England who loves the novel Jane Eyre and finds many similarities between herself and Bronte’s young heroine. Except, mostly, the fact that Jane Steele is a 5-time murderess. And, as far as I am aware, Jane Eyre had committed zero murders.
Jane Steele spends her early life living with her beautiful (and somewhat crazy) French mother in a cottage on an estate that she is told she will someday inherit. Jane doesn’t understand the intricacies or the legalities of this promise, but she always keeps the fact that Highgate House is legally her property in the back of her mind. When young Jane is orphaned, it is proposed that she will leave the estate where her horrible aunt and even more horrible cousin Edwin currently live, and be sent to one of those awfully tragic girls schools.
And thus, young Jane’s future as a killer is set in motion.
Yes, Jane heads off to the school, and it is every bit as awful as you might imagine. And even worse, as the headmaster is pretty much the devil. But Jane finds some goodness there, in the form of Clarke, a younger girl, left at the school by her wealthy, bohemian parents.
Jane and Clarke have adventures both at the school, and later, in London. When they sever their relationship, Jane is devastated, and nearly hits rock bottom. Until she sees an ad in the newspaper looking for a governess as Highgate House.
And Reader, this is when the book goes from really good to great.
Lyndsay Faye has created an amazing heroine in Jane Steele. Yes, Jane has done some bad things. Really terrible things. And yet, you can’t not root for her. You want nothing but the best for her and everyone in her life.
The supporting cast was also a delight. Charles Thornfield could go right up there with Captain Wentworth as a dashing romantic hero, as far as I’m concerned. Sardar Singh, Inspector Quillfeather, and the rest of the Thornfield household were also colorful, dynamic characters that I wanted to know more about. I loved the little details that we learned about these people. For instance, how Inspector Quillfeather always spoke in questions, or why the Sikh traditions and customs were so important to Charles and Sardar.
And the writing was top-notch. Not only was I on the edge of my seat for the last hundred pages, there were times when I actually laughed out loud. Like this exchange between Jane and her opium-addicted roommate:
“Lived at a place named Highgate House!” Tilly teased. “Well, I never. Ye was a genuine lady, like, with silks and velvets and a stick up your arse.”
“No velvets. No silks.” I folded the paper.
“But the stick?”
“Of course. They equip us with bum sticks from the cradle.”
Reader, I loved this book and am sad I had to finish it.
Oh this is awesome to hear because I downloaded it yesterday and just cracked into a few pages!! Can’t wait to read it all!
Yay! It’s such a fun book to read. I wasn’t prepared for how much I enjoyed it. Especially all the knives.
Seriously, the knives were amazing. I kept my iPad nearby and googled all the different weapons and Sikh martial arts. The whip-knife was my favorite.
Oh man, I also read Jane, that modernised YA retelling a few years ago, and it was so meh. It wasn’t even bad, it was just this thing that existed and didn’t really work. Jane Steele is going to be on my top 10 favourite books of 2016, I’m certain of that. I loved it so much. Normally, when I listen to a book in audio, it takes me a while to get through it. Not so with this. I’m behind on my own reviews, so I didn’t actually read more than your opening paragraph. I want to wait until I have time to write my own review of this awesome book. It was a clear 5-star read for me too, though.
Ok, ok, you’ve convinced me — adding this to my library hold list now.
I really hope it becomes one of the books of the year. It’s. so. good.
I had forgotten about the bum stick conversation, but you’re right, it’s hilarious. Also really enjoyed the newspaper man’s colorful speaking/writing style.
I should probably jump on this bandwagon now rather than later, huh. To the library!
Do it!! Do it now!!
I’ve been on the fence about this book, mostly because crime-and-murder is not my cuppa, so to speak. But mayyyyybe, I should try this? Maybe?
If you’re looking for a good contemporary story, last year I read Re Jane, which is a Korean-American adaptation, and I enjoyed it thoroughly.
This book is NOT a crime novel, and the murders very much are not the main focus of the story. While Jane Eyre meets The Punisher is a cool tagline, it also misrepresents the book quite a bit. There is no maybe about it, you should totally read this. I’m sure you’ll like it.
THIS SOUNDS AMAZING. I’m requesting it from the library immediately.