Ladies (and the gents who peruse our romance reviews, rock on) I have finally read a Milan. And it was okay. I will also state before anyone gets worried, I have already downloaded The Duchess War and shall be starting that shortly, but for now I read one.
Trade Me falls into a new genre category it appears, called New Adult. It is more saucy than say a Young Adult love story, but nowhere near as saucy as I require from my grown up romances. I don’t require erotica or any such (although, sometimes funsies), but thinking back on it, the 20 year olds have bland “funky times” is not surprising. Anywho, I’m getting ahead of myself…
This is the story of Tina Chen and Blake Reynolds. Tina is a scholarship student while double majoring at Berkeley, where Blake is heir to an Apple-like company starting classes a few years behind. They meet in a gen-ed class when Tina gets in an argument that Blake, with all of his wealth and fame, doesn’t understand her life. From this Blake decides that he wants to know how the other half lives and convinces Tina to trade lives with him for the rest of the semester. Events of a variety of kinds ensue, from family dramas to eating disorders to finally the previously mentioned “funky times”.
And so this is the issue I have with so many young adult and now I guess new adult books. Yes, I remember when I was a little sh*t, and thought I had the world all figured out. We all did. But there is a difference between that, and the shrew that is Tina, at 20, telling Blake exactly how her life is going to go. She has it entirely worked out. It’s so frustrating, especially as I get older and my patience gets even shorter, to hear about children knowing everything. I’m what most consider a “grown up” and I think that means, you’ve learned that you have absolutely nothing figured out and you’re just making it up as you go along. So reading about obnoxious children (which 20 is these days…) just isn’t my cup of tea anymore.
And the funny thing is, I still gave it 3 stars, because for all of my annoyance, it was well written. Ms. Milan is a charismatic, witty, fun writer, and I was quite impressed that while I didn’t like either character I still enjoyed her book overall. So my recommendation of this is pretty tepid unless you’re a Milan completist (I know you’re out there) or into the “New Adult” genre. Onto another, hopefully better, Milan!
Courtney Milan’s one fault as a writer is that she is never “saucy” enough. I always wish there were more sex scenes in her books. But, really. She’s so good otherwise.
I haven’t read this one yet, only her historicals, and they are very good. I normally stay far away from New Adult, but I will indeed dive in for her.
WORD on the saucy!
I can see why you might have found Tina a bit unsufferable. What I liked about her, which she has in common with so many of Milan’s heroines, is her quiet desperation, in this case because of her genuine poverty and the financial difficulties (and frequent irresponsibility) of her parents. I can absolutely see why she’d find Blake’s unbelievable wealth and his inability to understand her point of view so frustrating.
What Ashley said is true – Milan is not all that heavy on the sexy times. I don’t find this a problem, but then I don’t read romance primarily for the smexy, but for the smolder, banter and chemistry between the characters.
I don’t mind less “saucy times”, but I like some payout for the smolder, banter and chemistry. My favorites have a lovely balance between them all. If you’re that attracted to each other, something is bound to happen. That’s just how people work.
And as for Tina, while I understood where she was coming from, at the same time she was awful to Blake. I can understand being frustrated with him, but at the same time, her refusal to ever consider anything about his life was less than perfect was painfully immature. She read much more as a bratty teenager to me than an adult able to make real decisions.
But even through all that annoyance, I still am intrigued enough to try another. I’m just hoping for a character who’s a bit more mature.
This is Milan’s first foray into New Adult. Her historical heroines are all quite a lot more mature (if not actually older than Tina – I forget) than Tina. If you’re going to read The Duchess War next, I hope you enjoy Minnie and Robert. I certainly do.
Between you, Mrs. Julien, faintingviolet, Ashley you all have such excellent taste! You can’t be wrong. I refuse to believe it. Your reviews, no matter the genre, so reguarly match my own opinions. Therefore I shall plow ahead and read more Milan!
Cosign all of the above comments and your review.
If you’re looking for more sex scenes (and I feel you there; that’s something I enjoy as well,) interestingly Milan’s earlier books — Proof by Seduction and Trial by Fire — have a higher number of them, even though they aren’t quite as generally well-reviewed. I personally enjoyed them, but don’t necessarily make them a priority? Or do, idk. You do you!
But Trial by Fire is soooo bad.
I own a copy of Proof by Seduction (an actual book) and would be willing to mail to someone if they want it.
I’ve resigned myself to being the lone dissenter on TbD. I liked it! I grant that it’s a difficult romance (Ned is not a swoony hero) but as a Milan character piece I thought it was good. A bipolar hero and a heroine who runs an underground railroad for battered wives? Only Milan!
Holy smokes I just got name dropped! *victory lap around the office*
I’m so glad you enjoy and trust my reviews, it means the world to me :)
We are on the same page as usual, although I liked this book better than you did. I require saucy times. I just do.
There’s something about the connections made in the saucy times (just like real life) that I appreciate. I often can’t go to bed once I start a romance until we get to that point because it feels like the couple achieved something. It’s a book end point in the story.
My favourite thing about this whole book is that the one. time. Tina decides to cut loose and take a chance being reckless she gets hammered. I laughed loud and long at that.