CBR10Bingo: Alabama Pink (BINGO!)
I chose Chelsea Handler’s My Horizontal Life: A Collection of One-Night Stands for my Alabama Pink square, thinking I could breeze through it, laughing a bit along the way and then completely forgetting it as soon as I finished, but man, this book was so bad that I couldn’t get past the fifth chapter. I’d already powered my way through some terrible books this year, and the world is just too crappy a place right now, so I gave myself permission to put this one down without finishing. It’s poorly written. It’s juvenile. It’s aggressively offensive and provocative in the “LOOK AT ME I’M EDGY” school of comedy that’s become all too familiar and tiresome.
Within the first five chapters, she:
- peddles the most basic racist stereotypes about black men
- makes a painfully tone-deaf joke about photographing her “victims of sexual assault”
- dedicates an entire chapter to “sleeping with midgets”
That last one is what broke me. I’m still ashamed I even got that far.
I get that this is all part of her schtick, turning the tables on men by bragging about her own sexual exploits, saying awful things but then deflecting her awfulness with self-deprecation. I get that this was published “way back” in 2005, so maybe we shouldn’t hold her to our “lofty” 2018 standards, but what’s garbage now was garbage then, too.
I also get that humor is subjective, but not once did I crack a smile, let alone laugh. If you’re going to be EDGY, then at least be funny. Better yet: be funny and subversive. Chelsea Handler is neither of those things, and this book is not worth any more of my time.
So do all who live to read such books, but that is not for them to decide. All we have to decide is what to do with the books that are given to us.
P.S. Everyone hates this book and I am starting it tomorrow!
At least you’re likely to get a scathing review out of it. Yay?
I’m sorry this book sucked, dAvid. The Dud Avocado wasn’t great, either.
I was between this and Dud Avocado, so it wasn’t much of a choice. I feel good about the decision to put it down and walk away.
Narfna: This comment made the whole experience worth it.
Insert applause.gif [here]
I’m just glad someone got the joke!