Holy shitsticks, this was fun.
I’m sure Brandon Sanderson won’t be the last person to play around with evolving his/her fantasy world into some imagined future, but he was the first to do it, and that’s really something. This book actually happened sort of by accident. He was always planning on taking the world of the Mistborn trilogy (called Scadrial) and moving it forward to do two more trilogies, one set in a 1980s equivalent world, and a space opera where Allomancy (magic) exists side by side with SPACE STUFF. I mean, that’s so cool my brain can’t even process it. When it eventually happens I’m sure I’ll lose my mind over it. But on the way to those books, this one-book happened first. It’s set three hundred or so years after the events of the original trilogy, and what was once a traditional fantasy type feudal world is now a society in the midst of its industrial revolution. Trains are still new, electricity is coming, and by George there are guns everywhere.
It sort of has this steampunk/urban fantasy vibe going for it, only there are no Victorian social mores to get in the way (it’s actually super feminist because of the legacy of Vin from the original trilogy, although class is still an issue, as it was in the original trilogy) and steam power isn’t really a thing. So it’s not steampunk, but it sort of feels like it. What it does do is take the magic system and the creatures and the people and the culture from the original trilogy, and let them take their natural course down the evolutionary train. The result is something unlike anything I’ve read before and I was enamored of it almost immediately.
And that’s just the tone and the world. To top it all off, the characters and the dialogue are fantastic. I loved every single character almost instantly, even the ones that are supposedly hard to like. Our main character is former Lawkeeper Wax (aka Waxillium Ladrian, a lord who is descended from Breeze, one of the characters in the original trilogy). He’s just returned from the Roughs (sort of equivalent to the Old West) upon the death of his uncle and must now act as the head of House Ladrian, all the while still dealing with the fallout from a devastating loss. He goes straight for a while, but when a mysterious group calling themselves the Vanishers start pulling large heists and taking hostages, he’s pulled back into the lawkeeper game. His old partner Wayne has a big part in that, and Wayne is just delightful. I love him individually, and I love his dynamic with Wax.
The plot is more simple than the original trilogy, and that’s by design. This is essentially a crime/mystery/adventure novel taking place in a fantasy setting with elements of westerns, urban fantasy and steampunk all thrown in, and it works beautifully. In fact, it worked so beautifully, Sanderson decided to write another unplanned trilogy to continue the story before he hopped to the 80s and then outer space. So basically this book is like a fun prologue to a trilogy of books I’m assuming will feel similar to this one, but maybe have a bit more to do with the mythology of Scadrial (the planet) and the Cosmere in general (the Cosmere being the shared universe all his adult books are set in).
Anyway, whatever the fuck. I’m in for all of it, Sanderson’s whole thing. Sign me up for all the newsletters and take all my money. Bring it on.
Happy half Cannonball – I’m rooting for you to be first to 52 this year. I think you loved this book more than me, and you’ve read a lot more Sanderson so far. I had forgotten just how engrossing his writing is and can’t wait to read the next two books about Wax and the others. Just need to get through the Red Rising books first.
Holy crap, I didn’t even realize this was my half-cannonball. At this pace, I’ll be cannonballing by early April! Yeesh. Expandingbookshelf and badkittyuno are hot on my trail.
Don’t plant these ideas in my head, Malin. I’m super competitive if I let myself, which I haven’t ever in this “race” because I’ve always been so far behind at least a couple of people every year.
Red Rising book #3 just arrived today – WOOT!
I’ve been scared off this book due to mixed reviews on amazon (some HARSH) but if you loved it, I’m willing to give it a go! Happy half cannonball!
Oh, you should totally read it. I really liked it too and probably would have loved it if I remembered more details from the original trilogy (and the romance was more developed).
I really liked what he did with the romance. I didn’t think it was plausible Wax would, um (trying not to write spoilery comments), get over what happened quickly enough for there to be resolution. It’s definitely going to be a series-long arc.
Oh, I actually agree. He’s got some serious getting over stuff to do, but I would have liked a *bit* more. So is there going to be three more books in addition to Alloy of Law? I thought Bands of Mourning was the last one in this current series. Gah! I hate waiting for more books – at least Sanderson is a fast writer.
Alloy of Law was originally a one-off, and then he decided to do a full trilogy afterwards. So this one is sort of like a book-length prologue to the main event. There is one more coming in the trilogy, The Lost Metal, it looks like sadly not until 2018 though. He’s releasing Stormlight 3 first in 2017, along with a new YA project and the 2nd Rithmatist book, then the final Alloy era Mistborn book in Fall 2018. SO MUCH WAITING but at least he does 2-3 books per year, even if not the ones you really want.
Grumble. So now I have to decide if I’m going to read Shadows of Self and Bands of Mourning or whether I’ll wait until the last of this new trilogy comes out – at which point I may well have forgotten most of the plot of Alloy of Law. It’s not like I don’t have enough other stuff to keep me going…
You should read it now!
Those reviews were written by idiots. This book is awesome. It’s not like the original trilogy, though, so if you expect it to be you’re going to be disappointed. It’s its own thing.
Morning Star is on its way to me from the library… just a couple more days!!
I haven’t attempted any Sanderson yet, what do you lovely ‘ballers think would be a good entry point?
And happy half cannonball Narfna!!
Thank you!
I would say start with either Elantris, which was Sanderson’s first book, or with the original Mistborn trilogy. Elantris is weaker because it was his first, but it has less of a time commitment than Mistborn, since it’s a standalone (for now). I started with Elantris and I did okay :) The Mistborn trilogy is epic, though.
I have what might be a dumb question. I have this book for some reason (free download somehow? Where do all these books come from?) but none of the other Sanderson books so can I read Alloy of Law without having read any other Sanderson? I’d like to dip my toe in but I’m not sure this is way to do it?
Hmmmm. That’s tough. A large portion of my enjoyment of this book comes from having read its predecessors. It can definitely be done if you want to, for sure. You will understand what is going on. But you won’t get max enjoyment from it (and you will completely miss a ton of little things, or dismiss them as irrelevant).
I would honestly start with the original Mistborn book, The Final Empire. That’s more of an epic fantasy book (and a really excellent one), though, whereas this one is slighter and sillier and less of a commitment.
Ultimately it’s up to you, but I’m super glad I read them in order.
Oh, and also, it will spoil the original trilogy ending for you! That won’t matter if you aren’t planning on ever reading it, but I’m guessing if you like this book, you will want to read what came before it.